Editor’s note, May 2026: This article was first published in December 2022. We updated it to reflect changes to Subway My Way, Sub Club and Subway Australia’s Subcard closure.

Subway, the popular sandwich chain, offered a US loyalty program called Subway My Way when this article was written. The program rewarded customers through deals and points redeemable in store and through the app. Subway’s US loyalty offer now appears under Sub Club.

Advantages of Subway My Way

One of the main advantages of the Subway loyalty program is that it’s easy to join and use. Customers simply need to sign up for a card and scan it each time they make a purchase at Subway. They will earn points for each purchase, and those points can be redeemed for rewards such as free sandwiches and drinks. My first experience with the Subway My Way program was simple and easy. From lining up to purchasing my sub, I could download the app, register and scan my card to earn points. 

Another advantage of the Subway loyalty program is that it offers some flexibility in terms of how customers can earn and redeem points. For example, customers can earn extra points by purchasing certain items or participating in special promotions.

Additionally, the introduction of the Subway app has allowed customers to join and engage with the program in an easy and efficient way. Furthermore, customers can easily access their account and view their balance. The app also provides a platform for customers to order their food online and pick it up in store. This is extremely convenient during a busy workday as you are notified when the sandwich will be ready.

Disadvantages of Subway My Way

However, there are also some drawbacks to the Subway My Way rewards program. One of the main disadvantages is that the rewards can be relatively modest. Customers may have to make a lot of purchases in order to earn enough points for a free sandwich, and the rewards may not always be worth the effort.

Subway My Way recommendations

Offer more and better rewards. Subway could expand the range of rewards available and make them more valuable. For example, the company could offer free sandwiches, drinks, or sides, or it could offer discounts on larger purchases. 

Allow customers to customize their rewards. Subway could give customers the option to choose which rewards they want to earn and how they want to redeem their points. This could make the program feel more personalized and engaging. 

Provide more opportunities to earn points. Subway could offer more opportunities for customers to earn points, such as through special promotions or by purchasing certain items. This could make the program more rewarding and encourage more frequent purchases. 

Communicate the program more effectively. Subway could do a better job of promoting the loyalty program and explaining its benefits to customers. The company could use in-store signage, email marketing, or social media to let customers know about the program and encourage them to join. 

Overall, the Subway My Way program had some advantages. However, Subway could still improve its loyalty approach. Better rewards, stronger personalisation and clearer communication could make the program more useful for regular customers.

2026 update: Subway My Way, Sub Club and Subcard

Subway’s loyalty approach has changed since this article first appeared.

In the US, Subway now promotes Sub Club. Members earn points on purchases, receive exclusive offers and can access birthday rewards.

In Australia, Subway is closing the Subcard loyalty program in 2026. Members can earn reward dollars until 30 June 2026. They can redeem reward dollars until 31 August 2026.

This makes the original Subway My Way review more useful as a snapshot. It shows how simple app-based loyalty can work. It also shows why brands need to keep loyalty programs clear, valuable and well communicated.

Looking to step up your loyalty program strategy?

Our loyalty consultants have helped global brands take the critical steps to design effective loyalty programs, as well as support ongoing evolution to meet changing business and consumer expectations. Make your brand stand out by contacting us to talk with our expert loyalty consultants to understand how we can help you create a loyalty program strategy that keeps your customers coming back.